---
title: "ESG data asked of suppliers: duties, VSME, Scope 1 and 2 · Volcanic Minds"
description: "What a customer can ask you on sustainability, what you can decline, what the VSME standard is and how to answer every questionnaire once."
url: "https://volcanicminds.com/en/guides/esg-supplier-data"
lang: "en"
type: "second_level_page"
updated: "2026-11-16"
alternate: "https://volcanicminds.com/guides/esg-supplier-data"
summary: "An SME supplier has no sustainability reporting obligation: ESG data is requested by the customer, for its own report, for banks or for due diligence. From reports on financial year 2027, a customer subject to the CSRD cannot require a supplier with up to 1,000 employees to give more than the voluntary standard for SMEs provides. It pays to prepare it once and reuse it for everyone."
---

# The ESG data large customers ask of their suppliers

For the owner of a manufacturing SME that supplies a large company and receives questionnaires on energy, emissions, staff and safety: whether you must answer, what you can decline, what the voluntary standard for SMEs contains and how to collect the data without redoing it by hand for each customer.

## Are you required to give ESG data to your customer?

Not by law; by contract, possibly. Mandatory sustainability reporting, the CSRD, after the [Omnibus I directive](https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/HTML/?uri=OJ:L_202600470) of 24 February 2026 applies to companies that exceed both 450 million euros of net turnover and 1,000 employees on average, for financial years starting from 1 January 2027. A 60-person SME is not subject. The data is requested by a customer that is, because its sustainability report covers its value chain; or by a bank, which the Commission advises to show the same restraint; or by a customer that must carry out due diligence on its suppliers.

| Rule | Who it covers | From when |
| --- | --- | --- |
| CSRD, sustainability reporting | companies above 450 million turnover and 1,000 employees | financial years from 1 January 2027 |
| CSRD, first wave | large public-interest entities already subject | financial years 2024-2026, exemptible below the new thresholds in 2025 and 2026 |
| CSDDD, value chain due diligence | companies above 5,000 employees and 1.5 billion turnover | from 26 July 2029 |
| voluntary standard for SMEs (VSME) | whoever chooses to use it, or is asked to | recommended from 2025, regulation from 2026 |

In Italy the CSRD came in with Legislative Decree 125/2024, and [Decree-Law 95/2025](https://www.normattiva.it/uri-res/N2Ls?urn:nir:stato:decreto.legge:2025-06-30;95~art10) moved its dates to 2027 and 2028, transposing the European postponement of [Directive 2025/794](https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/HTML/?uri=OJ:L_202500794). Omnibus I must be transposed by 19 March 2027; as of 16 November 2026 we found no Italian decree doing so (our check).

The customer asks because your emissions are part of its own. In the GHG Protocol, the reference standard for counting emissions, those of purchased goods are category 1 of the customer's indirect emissions, Scope 3, and the standard calls them «by definition the direct emissions of another entity». It is not an isolated request: among Italian manufacturing firms with at least 10 employees that took environmental sustainability actions in 2021 and 2022, 20.9% monitored the environmental impact of their suppliers, according to [ISTAT](https://www.istat.it/wp-content/uploads/2025/05/Statistica-focus-sostenibilita-ambientale-manifattura_Anno-2022.pdf), the Italian national statistics institute.

### What about CBAM?

It is a different obligation, which does not come through the customer. If you yourself import iron and steel, aluminium, cement or fertilisers from outside the Union, you are an importer under the carbon border adjustment mechanism. From 1 January 2026 you are exempt if in a calendar year you import no more than 50 tonnes net of these goods in total, under [Regulation (EU) 2025/2083](https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/HTML/?uri=OJ:L_202502083); above the threshold, the obligations apply to all imports of that year.

## What can the customer ask of you, and what can you decline?

It can ask for anything; you are bound to give, and only if you sign it, what falls within the voluntary standard. The Omnibus I directive introduced a value chain cap: a supplier that had on average no more than 1,000 employees in the previous financial year is a protected undertaking and, for the customer's sustainability report, has the right to decline information that goes beyond the voluntary standard. The customer cannot put requests exceeding it into contracts, and if it does, that clause is not binding while the rest of the contract stands. When it asks for more, it must tell you which data exceeds the standard and that you have the right not to give it. To establish whether you are protected, a self-declaration from you can be enough. The threshold is 1,000 employees, not the 250 of the SME definition: the cap also protects mid-sized and larger companies.

The cap applies from financial years beginning on or after 1 January 2027, under article 4 of [Delegated Regulation (EU) 2026/1560](https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/HTML/?uri=OJ:L_202601560), and in Italy after Omnibus I is transposed. Before that only [Recommendation (EU) 2025/1710](https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/HTML/?uri=OJ:L_202501710) applies, which asks companies subject to reporting and banks to «limit as far as possible» their requests to SMEs to the voluntary standard, without binding them. A request you receive in 2026 for the 2025 or 2026 report, then, is not covered by the cap (our reading).

Three cases stay outside. The cap does not touch requests for due diligence, nor those for other purposes, such as the customer's risk management; and it does not prevent sharing data on your own initiative, such as what is already commonly exchanged in your sector. **The cap does not stop the customer from asking: it gives you the right not to answer beyond the standard, and only for its sustainability report.**

| Area | What the cap covers, above 10 employees | Standard item |
| --- | --- | --- |
| general | basic information about the undertaking | B1 |
| energy and emissions | total energy consumption in MWh, Scope 1 and 2 emissions | B3 |
| water and waste | water withdrawal, hazardous and non-hazardous waste, share recycled | B6, B7 |
| workforce | employees by contract type and gender, turnover | B8, C5 |
| safety | number and rate of recordable work-related accidents | B9 |
| pay and training | minimum wage, collective bargaining, average training hours | B10 |
| conduct | markets and business relationships, code of conduct, complaints, confirmed incidents | C1, C6, C7 |

For undertakings with 10 employees or fewer the cap is narrower: energy, emissions, water and waste are not part of it. Scope 3, pollution and biodiversity do not appear in the list: for the customer's report, a protected supplier may decline them (our reading of annex II of the regulation).

## What is the VSME standard?

It is the voluntary sustainability reporting standard for SMEs; the acronym stands for Voluntary SME standard. The Commission adopted it with the recommendation of 30 July 2025, and with the delegated regulation of 3 July 2026, published on 21 September, made it the voluntary standard to which the cap is tied. It has two modules: the basic one, with eleven items from B1 to B11, and the comprehensive one, with nine items from C1 to C9 to add when needed.

The core of customer requests is item B3. It asks for total energy consumption in MWh, split between electricity and fuels and, if you have the data, between renewable and non-renewable; and estimated gross emissions in tonnes of CO2 equivalent, counted under the 2004 GHG Protocol: Scope 1 and location-based Scope 2, calculated on the grid average. For undertakings with 10 employees or fewer, in the regulation B3 is voluntary. Scope 3 sits in the comprehensive module, and the 2025 recommendation considers it appropriate only for certain activities.

The advantage for whoever answers is one: a common format. If you prepare your report with the voluntary standard, you already have the answer to much of each questionnaire, because companies subject to reporting and banks are invited to ask for that data and nothing else.

## How are energy and Scope 1 and 2 emissions calculated?

Starting from the consumption you pay for. Scope 1 is direct emissions from sources you own or control: gas for the boiler or furnaces, diesel for company vehicles, refrigerant gas leaking from systems. Scope 2 is emissions from generating the electricity you buy. Everything else, from purchased materials to transport outsourced to others, is Scope 3.

| Item | Where you find the data | Unit |
| --- | --- | --- |
| electricity | utility bills, or meter readings | kWh |
| natural gas | utility bills | standard cubic metres |
| diesel and petrol for vehicles | fuel invoices, fuel cards | litres |
| refrigerant gases | maintenance reports for the systems | kg topped up |
| employees by contract and gender | payroll, staff records | headcount or full-time equivalents |
| accidents | accident reports and hours worked | number and rate |
| training | course register and certificates | hours per employee |

Each consumption is multiplied by an emission factor. For electricity consumed in Italy, the national factor of [ISPRA](https://www.isprambiente.gov.it/files2026/pubblicazioni/rapporti/r430-2026-2.pdf), the Italian public institute for environmental protection, is 194.04 grams of CO2 equivalent per kWh in 2024, final figure, and 201.01 in 2025, preliminary figure, counting methane and nitrous oxide too; for CO2 alone they are 192.6 and 199.6. ISPRA itself indicates them for an approximate estimate of indirect emissions. A company that consumed 400,000 kWh in 2024 therefore has about 77.6 tonnes of CO2 equivalent of location-based Scope 2 (the consumption is invented, the calculation is not). For fuels, the [Italian Ministry of the Environment](https://www.mase.gov.it/portale/monitoraggio-delle-emissioni-di-gas-ad-effetto-serra-per-gli-impianti-stazionari) publishes the national standard parameters used for installations under emissions trading, but the most recent table listed on the page is valid until 2019: agree with your customer or adviser which factors to use, and write the source next to the number.

The customer then allocates. One of the methods of the Scope 3 standard is for the buyer to obtain from the supplier its total emissions and the buyer's share of the supplier's production, in quantity or in revenue. That is why many questionnaires ask for the total and an allocation key, and why it pays to give the total once and the share customer by customer.

## How do you answer three different questionnaires once?

With a single file, organised on the items of the voluntary standard, updated once a year, from which you draw the answers for each customer. Questionnaires differ in form, but largely ask for the same things: energy, emissions, workforce, safety, policies.

First you collect the year's data, each figure with its source document: the bill, the invoice, the payroll summary. Then you calculate emissions with stated, dated factors. Then, for each customer question, you note which item of the standard it matches; whatever falls outside is a commercial choice, not an obligation, and from 2027 you can say so. Keep track of what you gave each customer and in which version, because next year they will ask again and want to compare. It is the same method we describe for security questionnaires in the guide [NIS2: what the customer asks](/guides/nis2-supplier-requirements).

The part most often got wrong is not the calculation, it is provenance. **Tracking for every data point the moment, the unit it came from and its validation status** (as we explain in [calculations and specialist rules](/frequently-asked-questions#regole-di-dominio)), when the customer or the auditor asks where a number comes from, the answer is already there.

**Would you rather talk it through?**

Book a call with people who work on these topics every day: we will look at your case together.

- [Book a call](https://vms.srl/booking)

## Do you need software, and which?

For a company with one site and two customers asking, a well built spreadsheet is enough: one sheet per item of the standard, one row per month, the source column. Software is needed when there is more than one site, data comes from several people every month, customers ask for different formats, or when you are the one collecting data from your own suppliers. When a spreadsheet still holds and when to move to business software is covered in general in the guide [Excel or business software](/guides/excel-or-business-software).

It is a problem we know. In an ESG platform for the supply chain that we built, each company registers its operating units and consumption in six categories: electricity, fuel, refrigerant, water, heat and steam, direct process emissions. The platform converts consumption into tonnes of CO2 equivalent with factors compliant with ISO 14064 and the GHG Protocol, provided by an expert partner; before sharing, it flags the categories not yet filled in for each operating unit, then sends each customer its allocated emissions, in the same format in which it receives those of its suppliers ([the case study](/case-studies/supply-chain-esg-platform), with the 89% increase in data completeness it reports, an internal estimate made with the client). A supplier not yet registered can find the data attributed to it and claim it; how to open a platform to suppliers without them seeing more than they should is in the guide on the [portal for suppliers, subcontractors and partners](/guides/supplier-portal).

On cost, a custom MVP starts at 10,000 € ([our price ranges](/frequently-asked-questions#fasce-di-prezzo)); off-the-shelf reporting platforms have their own price lists. Before choosing, check whether the tool exports in the format of the voluntary standard and whether it connects to your business systems and payroll, because that is where the data lives.

## An example: the 60-person metalworking firm supplying automotive

A 60-person metalworking firm with one plant supplies components to an automotive group and to two machine builders. In 2026 it receives three questionnaires: the first asks for energy and Scope 1 and 2 emissions, the second Scope 3 too and a human rights policy, the third accidents and training hours. The details are invented, to be replaced with yours.

The owner collects the 2025 data once: electricity and gas bills, diesel invoices for the two vans, maintenance reports for the air conditioning systems, the staff summary, accident reports and the course register. With the adviser they choose the emission factors, write them next to the numbers and prepare the report with the basic module of the voluntary standard. To the first and third customers they send the requested items, with the share of revenue from each as the allocation key. To the second they answer on the items of the standard and, for Scope 3, propose a date, because the figure does not exist yet.

From financial year 2027 the picture changes: for the automotive group's sustainability report, if the group is subject to the CSRD, the firm is a protected supplier and Scope 3 is beyond the cap. If the group asks for it for due diligence, though, the cap does not apply, and the answer remains a choice to negotiate.

## Frequently asked questions

### Is an SME required to give ESG data to its customers?

Not by law: after the Omnibus I directive the CSRD covers companies above 450 million turnover and 1,000 employees. The obligation can arise from the contract with the customer. From financial years 2027, for the customer's sustainability report, a supplier with up to 1,000 employees can decline data beyond the voluntary standard.

### What is the VSME standard?

It is the voluntary sustainability reporting standard for SMEs, adopted by the European Commission with Recommendation 2025/1710 and then with Delegated Regulation 2026/1560. It has a basic module with eleven items, from B1 to B11, and a comprehensive module with nine items, from C1 to C9.

### From when does the cap on data a customer can ask for apply?

From financial years beginning on or after 1 January 2027, under Delegated Regulation (EU) 2026/1560, and in Italy after the transposition of the Omnibus I directive, due by 19 March 2027. Requests for the 2025 and 2026 reports are covered only by Recommendation 2025/1710, which is not binding.

### Can the customer ask me for Scope 3?

It can ask, but from financial years 2027 Scope 3 is beyond the value chain cap: for the customer's sustainability report, a supplier with up to 1,000 employees may decline it. The cap does not apply if the customer asks for it for due diligence or for its own risk management.

### What are Scope 1 and Scope 2 emissions?

Under the GHG Protocol, Scope 1 is direct emissions from sources you own or control, such as boilers, furnaces and company vehicles; Scope 2 is emissions from generating the electricity you buy. All other indirect emissions, from purchased materials to transport outsourced to others, are Scope 3.

### Which emission factor is used for electricity in Italy?

The national ISPRA factor for electricity consumption: 194.04 grams of CO2 equivalent per kWh in 2024, final figure, and 201.01 in 2025, preliminary figure. Multiplied by the kWh on the bills, it gives an estimate of location-based Scope 2, the one required by the voluntary standard.

### What happens if a clause asks for more data than the standard?

For sustainability reporting, from financial years 2027 that clause is not binding on a supplier with up to 1,000 employees, while the rest of the contract stands. The customer must tell you which data exceeds the voluntary standard and that you have the right not to give it.

### Do I need software for ESG data?

With one site and few customers, a spreadsheet organised on the items of the voluntary standard, with the source of every number, is enough. Software pays off when there is more than one site, data comes from several people every month, customers ask for different formats or you must collect data from your own suppliers.

## Three customers, three ESG questionnaires?

Tell us how you collect the data today, in an introductory call, free and with no commitment: we tell you whether a well built spreadsheet is enough or what it would take custom.

- [Let's talk about your project](/en/contacts)

## Articles on the same topics.

*Keep reading*

- [European AI Act who does it really affect?](/en/insights/eu-ai-act-deployer-business.md): The EU AI Act doesn't only target those who build the models, but those who use AI in business. What applies from 2 August 2026 and what moves to 2027-2028.
- [Digital accessibility is not a badge](/en/insights/why-accessibility-overlays-fail.md): Discover why accessibility overlays fail WCAG 2.2 AA compliance and why building native accessibility is crucial for legal and commercial success.
- [Google Analytics, GDPR and the Plausible alternative](/en/insights/google-analytics-gdpr-alternative-plausible.md): Is Google Analytics GDPR compliant? Why Plausible Analytics is the privacy-first, cookie-less alternative for European businesses and their data.
